Search blog.co.uk

Whose responsibility is it?

by lyndlj @ 2008-01-10 - 20:32:49

A baby has had its very short life ended and the young parents have suffered a loss that all parents fear, that of the loss of a child.

A faulty boiler explodes and a child dies, not the first even of this kind but surely it should be the last?

The first night in a new house, supplied by the council and this tragedy occurs, but who is responsible for what happened? Had the parents been aware of the dangers of this type of boiler blowing up and raining scalding hot water on their chid it is safe to say that they would not have placed the child in that room in that place, perhaps even refused to move in to the house until it was replaced.

This was a council property, was this their responsibility, especially in the light of the same thing happening four years ago? Surely when a tenant moves out and they take the proerty back then they should check all equipment and replace what needs replacing? They do in my district, well most of the time anyway.

They had knowledge of this happening before, should they have replaced all the boilers of this kind that were in their proerties in order to prevent such a thing happening again instead of keeping quiet about what had happened?

Are the boiler manufacturers at fault for having faulty thermostats? But that would only apply had they been made in this country where they have to pass rigourus tests to obtain the seal of approval.

Personally I believe that the Council should carry the blame for this one for two reasons, one not advising or making it publicly known that these particular types of boliers have a danger of blowing up and two, for not replacing them in the properties that they own and rent out to young couples with young children.

As the courts have so rightly declared, this was an accident waiting to happen that could have been avoided.

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

sexygeordiegirlsexygeordiegirl [Member]
2008-01-10 @ 20:45

Obviosuly this was not the parents fault at all. How would they know? I wouldnt know thats for sure. I agree that the council are at fault... As would a private landlord if they let someone move into their property without having everything checked and to be in full working order... So why should it be any different for the council who are supplying the house?

Although on this note... I must add that I do not agree with the council giving young families or anyone for that matter houses or anything for nothing. I dont agree with the amount of benifits that are given out... I think that if people honestly need these benifits and they have tried other means first (as in searched properly for ANY job) then yes the council should help to stop people living on the streets etc, but they shouldnt give it for free... They should have to work for it... Even if its just the type of work that is usually volinteer - working in charity shops, cleaning parks and streets... Other things like that.

I dont agree with the amount of people who are taking our hard earned tax just because they are too lazy to work.

sweetladyjanesweetladyjane pro
2008-01-10 @ 20:53

I agree the fault of this lies on the council. Shame on them for housing people in unsafe places.

Mrs_FMrs_F [Member]
2008-01-10 @ 21:13

Hard to say. I do not know all the facts here.

It seems to me that the council should have ensured that carried out a full risk assessment on the property before it was let. If this was done then the fault might lie with the contractors if they failed to spot the faulty boiler otherwise, if this was not done then it lies with the council. Unless it would have been impossible for anyone to detect the fault in which case maybe it is just an unfortunate accident and no one is to blame. Sometimes accidents cannot be predicted and stuff just happens.

X

mad-poetmad-poet [Member]
2008-01-10 @ 21:57

As an ex plumber (35 year ago)I can see that this typ of terrible accident could hapen in almost any house given the wrong set of cicumstances.
Although sypathy for all invoved is obviose, shit hapens and always will,I think we are too quick to look for someone to blame for what may be avoidable but not realy forseeable

lyndljlyndlj pro
2008-02-01 @ 16:20

In normal circumstances I would agree with you, but, the council knew that these boilers had faulty thermostats as it had already happened once before, they kept this knowledge quiet, therefore it is their responsibility.

Onlineshops [Visitor]
http://www.onlineshops.no
2008-01-11 @ 23:42

Shopping online? - Try our website with online shops by category and pages for United Kingdom, United States and the Scandinavien countries.

We would be very happy if you could please consider to have a link til Onlineshops.no on your blog. Thank you in advance!

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.